Featured Business, Start a Personalized Candy Wrapper Business:  Wrapcandy.com

Pay-Per-Click Fraud Exposed--Part II

According to Andy Jones, a member of the Best Practices Search Engine Forums, fraudulent clicks are just another aspect of the business. "Any of us that use AdWords or any other PPC has to pay for a certain percentage of fraudulent clicks," he said in a forum discussion. "I factor it in as a cost of doing business."

Can you believe that? In other words, he's saying, I know the pay-per-click companies are stealing my money, but it's okay, because I've considered that fact ahead of time.

Unfortunately, that mentality is pervasive among pay-per-click advertisers. No wonder the pay-per-click companies aren't making stopping pay-per-click fraud a top priority. Who can blame them? If their advertisers don't care, why should they? Heck, with all of the money the pay-per-click companies are making, it's actually more cost effective to issue an occasional refund, than to develop technology to eliminate click fraud.

And if you read between the lines of the following statement, Google even admitted as much:

In a recent filing to the Securities and Exchange Commission, Google acknowledged, "We are exposed to the risk of fraudulent clicks on our ads. We have regularly paid refunds related to fraudulent clicks and expect to do so in the future. If we are unable to stop this fraudulent activity, these refunds may increase. If we find new evidence of past fraudulent clicks, we may have to issue refunds retroactively of amounts previously paid to our Google Network members."

That statement doesn't exactly instill any confidence, now does it?

And if Overture is asked about click fraud, they'll just issue their standard company line:

"Our Click Protection System is sophisticated software that evaluates each of our advertisers' clicks. This software makes decisions as to the validity of any click. Our Click Protection System uses search and click data to make both rules-based inferences and pattern recognition-based inferences about which clicks are valid clicks. We have two patents pending related to this technology, so we cannot currently disclose too many details about the methods we use."

Do you honestly think newspaper, magazine, radio or tv advertisers would just sit back and let those media get away with blatantly stealing their money? You know they wouldn't.

Then why do pay-per-click advertisers allow it? I don't know the exact answer to that question, but I have my theories: First of all, you're talking about a whole different level of sophistication with pay-per-click advertisers, compared to media advertisers. Many pay-per-click advertisers don't even know how to access or even analyze their log files, so they have no idea how much money is actually being stolen from them.

In addition, some pay-per-click advertisers are making more money than they've ever made before. And rather than upset the apple cart, they'd rather keep quiet and allow the vicious cycle of click fraud to continue, so that they can keep cashing those big checks.

I also suspect many advertisers are afraid that if they complain too loudly, they may be penalized in the search engines, in regard to their free listings.

If my theories are accurate, silence is one heck of a trade off, if you ask me. Why? Because according to a report on MediaPost, an online study done by Clicklab revealed that fraudulent clicks can account for more than 50 percent of your total clicks.

So, if the goal of pay-per-click search engines is to bring lucrative, targeted traffic to your web site, what are the pay-per-click search engines doing about the click fraud epidemic, to prevent abuse that needlessly drive up your costs and reduce your ROI?

Unfortunately, since so many pay-per-click advertisers are willing to play the role of "lambs going to slaughter," the pay-per-click companies really don't have to do anything.

In the meantime, your ROI is going to continue to plummet, and the pay-per-click companies are going to continue to milk those cash cows (AKA) pay-per-click advertisers, for all they're worth!

About The Author

Dean Phillips is an Internet marketing expert, writer, publisher and entrepreneur. Questions? Comments? Dean can be reached at mailto: dean@lets-make-money.net.

Visit his website at: http://www.lets-make-money.net

Conventions Conclude, Fall Campaign Begins: NFIB Looks for More ... MarketWatch - 7 hours ago Of the 47 million uninsured Americans in 2006(1), 28 million were small business owners, employees or their dependents(2). Rising healthcare costs, a major ...

How to Prepare Your Small Business for a Disaster U.S. News & World Report, DC - 3 hours ago By Matthew Bandyk When major disasters like Hurricane Gustav dominate the press, small-business owners are reminded of how quickly everything they work for ...

St. Louis American

Chicago IT Firm Named National Minority Small Business of the Year ... MarketWatch - 11 hours ago George Burciaga, a 34-year old Latino entrepreneur and president of smarTECHS.net, Inc., was named today as Minority Small Business Person of the Year ... SBA coaches minority businesses in forging strategic alliances St. Louis American Stephen Hayes Recognized for Increasing Trade Relations with Africa MarketWatch all 14 news articles

Web offers big solutions for small business Sydney Morning Herald, Australia - 10 hours ago HISTORICALLY, small business has had no chance of competing with large corporations in the marketing area. The costs of using traditional advertising ...

Pasco man named 'Minority Small Business Person of Year' Mid Columbia Tri City Herald, WA - 1 hour ago A Pasco businessman has been recognized by the US Small Business Administration Seattle District. Stuart W. Fricke is president and owner of White Shield ...

The Money Times

Small Business Offers Only Employment Bright Spot bMighty.com, NY - 1 hour ago Small businesses actually added 20000 jobs in August, even as larger companies shed more than 50000 jobs. The economy as a whole registered a seasonaly ... ADP National Employment Report Shows US Employment Decreased by ... CNNMoney.com Payroll report: Nation loses 33000 jobs in August Bizjournals.com Small Businesses Add 20000 Jobs in August IndustryWeek CNNMoney.com all 88 news articles

CVBT: "McCain or Obama: Same old, same old for small business" Huffington Post, NY - 29 minutes ago Today, the Central Valley Business Times ran an interview with the President of the American Small Business League, Lloyd Chapman. ...

Funding Small Business Small Business Journal - 6 hours ago Directory of small business loans solutions. Find providers. Need to Write a Business Plan? Get UPB Need to write a business plan, but don't have time to ... Small Business Development Small Business Journal all 9 news articles

Wall Street Journal Blogs

Entrepreneurs Ask McCain and Obama: What Will You do for Small ... MarketWatch - Sep 4, 2008 Of the questions submitted, Entrepreneur.com editors will select the top inquiries relating to small business and go straight to the source to get the ... Small Business Looks at Where Candidates Fall on Its Issues Wall Street Journal McCain or Obama: Who Deserves the Small Business Vote? Wall Street Journal Blogs all 8 news articles

Hearing- "Examining Expiring Tax Incentives and the Needs of Small ... Trading Markets (press release), CA - 1 hour ago Testifying will be a diverse group of small business owners who will share their insights and priorities as Congress works on adoption of a final proposal. ...